The short answer
If you're buying one, buy the Olay. It's $29.99 against $109, it rates 4.6 / 5 against 4.5 / 5 on Amazon Australia, and it's a moisturiser, which you need anyway.
The Estée Lauder is a serum. It goes on under a moisturiser, so it's an extra step, not a replacement. It earns its place only once the basics are already sorted.
Olay Regenerist vs Advanced Night Repair, side by side
| Olay Regenerist Collagen Peptide 24 | Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair | |
|---|---|---|
| Price today | $29.99 | $109 |
| Amazon AU rating | 4.6 / 5 | 4.5 / 5 |
| What it is | A face cream | A night serum |
| Built on | Peptides and niacinamide | Hyaluronic acid |
| Where it goes | Last, as your moisturiser | Before your moisturiser |
| The catch | Thick, and needs a minute to sink in | Works over weeks, at $109 |
What the Olay does
Peptides and niacinamide in a fragrance-free cream that plumps fine lines over a few weeks rather than overnight. At $29.99 it undercuts most peptide creams, though it's thicker than it looks and needs a minute to sink in.
Fragrance-free is worth more than it sounds. If your skin reacts to products, fragrance is the first thing to take out, and at this price you lose nothing by doing so.
What the Estée Lauder does
A lightweight nighttime serum with hyaluronic acid that sinks in before your moisturiser goes on. It works on a scale of weeks rather than days, and at $109 that patience is the real cost.
A serum built on hyaluronic acid holds water in the top layers of skin. Skin looks less tired and takes makeup better. That is real, and it is not dramatic. Judge it at three months, not in week one.
What the $79.01 buys
Texture, mostly, and a famous brown bottle. The serum is lighter and disappears faster. It doesn't buy a higher rating: buyers rate the $29.99 cream a little above it.
That is the pattern across this site. Past a certain point, more money buys a nicer experience, not a better result.
Can you use both?
Yes, and they don't clash: serum first, then the cream over it. Whether you should is a different question. If you don't yet wear sunscreen every day, that is where the next $30 belongs, ahead of any serum.
So which one
The Olay, for nearly everyone. I'd add the Estée Lauder only for someone who already has a moisturiser and a daily sunscreen they like, wants one more step, and will give it three months.
Sources: Estée Lauder Australia: Advanced Night Repair Synchronized Multi-Recovery Complex (checked 2026-10-28); Olay: Regenerist Collagen Peptide 24 (checked 2026-10-28). Prices and ratings: the Amazon Australia listings linked above.