Acids, compared

Alpha-H Liquid Gold vs Paula's Choice 2% BHA: which acid for which skin?

$84.95 against $54. One is glycolic and one is salicylic, and they fix different things.

Updated 2026-11-15 ยท prices from Amazon Australia

Disclosure: HarshaHQ is an Amazon Associate and earns from qualifying purchases, and earns a commission from any other retailer linked here. It costs you nothing extra. Prices are what each retailer was charging when this page was last built. How we research these pages.

The short answer

They are two different acids for two different complaints. Alpha-H Liquid Gold is glycolic, which works on the surface: dullness, rough texture, uneven tone. Paula's Choice 2% BHA is salicylic, which works inside the pore: blackheads, congestion, the small bumps that never come to a head.

Buy for the complaint, not the price. And buy one. Using both on the same night is where most irritation starts.

Alpha-H Liquid Gold vs Paula's Choice 2% BHA, side by side

 Alpha-H Liquid GoldPaula's Choice 2% BHA
Price today$84.95$54
Amazon AU rating4.6 / 54.4 / 5
The acid5% glycolic (an AHA)2% salicylic (a BHA)
Where it worksOn the surfaceInside the pore
Buy it forDullness, rough texture, uneven toneBlackheads, congestion, small bumps
The catchStings if you use it more than three nights a weekNothing about using it feels like it is working

What glycolic acid does, and what Liquid Gold is

A 5% glycolic treatment you sweep on at night and leave, from an Australian brand that was doing acids before they went mainstream. Alpha-H says start once a week and build to three nights at most, because more than that stings.

Glycolic is the smallest of the alpha hydroxy acids. It loosens the bonds holding dead cells on the top layer of skin, so they leave sooner and the newer skin underneath shows. That is the glow, and it's a surface effect. It does little for a blocked pore.

Alpha-H's own advice is three nights a week, and it says plainly that nightly use can over-exfoliate. It also says not to follow it with other products, because they blunt the treatment.

Alpha-H Liquid Gold
Alpha-H Liquid Gold
Step 3: Exfoliant · 4.6 / 5 on Amazon AU

What salicylic acid does, and what the Paula's Choice is

Salicylic acid that gets down inside the pore rather than polishing the surface, which is why it works on blackheads and the small bumps that never come to a head. Nothing about using it feels like it is working.

Salicylic acid is oil-soluble, which is the whole difference. It can get into a pore that is full of oil, where a water-loving acid like glycolic stays on top. So it suits skin that congests: a shiny T-zone, blackheads on the nose, bumps along the jaw.

Its honest drawback is that it's quiet. There's no tingle and no next-morning glow to tell you it's doing anything, so people stop before it has had a few weeks to work.

Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant
Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant
Step 4: Serum · 4.4 / 5 on Amazon AU

Can you use both?

Not on the same night. Two leave-on acids stacked is the fastest route to a stripped, stinging face, and Alpha-H's own directions tell you not to layer anything over Liquid Gold.

On different nights, some skin copes. Most skin doesn't need to find out. One acid used steadily for two months tells you more than two acids used nervously for two weeks. The fuller argument is in which skincare steps you can skip.

Whichever you pick, wear sunscreen the next morning. Exfoliated skin burns more easily, and in Australia that matters for most of the year.

So which one

If your skin is oily or congested, the Paula's Choice. It's $30.95 cheaper and it's aimed at the problem you have. If your skin is clear but flat and rough, Liquid Gold, three nights a week and no more.

If you can't tell which you are, I'd start with the Paula's Choice. In an Australian summer more faces are congested than dull.

Sources: Alpha-H: What is Liquid Gold and how to use it (checked 2026-11-15); Alpha-H: Liquid Gold with 5% Glycolic Acid (checked 2026-10-28); Paula's Choice Australia: Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant (checked 2026-10-28). Prices and ratings: the Amazon Australia listings linked above.